Hi All,
I need some advice and some guidance on a case when a buyer returned an item different than what she received from us, and Amazon, after receiving our evidence that the returned item is wrong, told us that 'the buyer is entitled for a full refund'.
I would be particularly interested to hear opinion and guidance from Amazon's moderators (copied!)
The item is a pair of Tory Burch designer shoes, order number 112-6067122-8716253, FBM. The buyer opened a return request, and then returned a different pair of shoes: It suffices to say that the pair returned is of a different size from the pair the buyer received - trivially a different pair then.
Sadly, our experience on returns of Tory Burch shoes is that in 5-10% of the returns the buyer swaps as above. So, we are very careful to document: A sequence of photos of the shoes we pack to ship out (next to the shipping label) and a full video of each return's processing starting with the opening of the sealed package.
Normally, when we realize that we got the wrong item, we wait for Amazon to issue an auto-refund, and then we file a safe-T and present our evidence. This works most of the time. Great solution.
But sometimes Amazon's auto-refund is delayed (or never happens). One time before (when such a delay happened), the buyer filed A-Z, got auto-refund on the A-Z, we appealed (with the evidence as above) and our appeal was approved.
This time, on order 112-6067122-8716253, things were completely different: The auto-refund was delayed and the buyer filed A-Z. A few hours later, the auto-refund went through (full refund save the original shipping, since the return reason was remorse, 'size does not fit'). We presented to the A-Z case the evidence that we got a wrong item (photos +explanation) and, still, the A-Z was ruled against us, for a full refund (including original shipping, on a remorse return!) And we got a defect at the ODR.
To recall, per Amazon's rules, safe-T is not allowed once A-Z was filed. So, we appealed the A-Z, providing again the unambiguous evidence that the wrong item was returned to us, and the appeal was denied almost instantly since 'We (Amazon) have reviewed all available information and determined that the buyer is eligible for a full refund.' Really? Full refund (+ a defect to us) when the wrong item was returned?
As said, we will greatly appreciate advice and help. We do not believe that this is something that should have happened, but do not know what to do in order to rectify the situation.
Best Wishes,
Ele's Fashion
@Xander_Amazon @Jim_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Danny_Amazon @Quincy_Amazon @Connor_Amazon @Emet_Amazon @Nano_Amazon @Cade_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Micah_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @Jameson_Amazon @KJ_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Glenn_Amazon @CR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon