Seller Forums
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

Cross-marketplace ASIN variations abuse and review manipulation

Dear Amazon Seller Support,

I am writing to follow up on Case ID 13183224902 and 13182321402 regarding suspected cross-marketplace ASIN variation abuse and review manipulation.

The evidence indicates that materially different products are being grouped into the same variation families across multiple Amazon marketplaces, potentially allowing reviews and ratings from unrelated or older products to increase the apparent review history of newly launched listings.

I am surprised and concerned that no meaningful action appears to have been taken against the sellers reported.

This type of abuse can seriously damage legitimate sellers. A seller may spend five years building a product's sales history, customer trust, and reviews, only to see a competitor copy the product and obtain a comparable review count within weeks by linking, merging, or injecting older ASINs into complex variation structures.

In this case, we have identified what appears to be a complex cross-marketplace network involving Canada, Australia, Europe, and the United Kingdom that ultimately benefits newer listings in the United States. We are seeing materially different ASINs, older products, duplicated pack variations, and apparently unrelated listings being connected across marketplaces.

This does not appear to be an isolated listing error. The repeated structure and use of multiple marketplaces suggest a systematic strategy intended to transfer or aggregate review history around newer products.

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

29 views
3 replies
Tags:Product reviews
30
Reply
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

Cross-marketplace ASIN variations abuse and review manipulation

Dear Amazon Seller Support,

I am writing to follow up on Case ID 13183224902 and 13182321402 regarding suspected cross-marketplace ASIN variation abuse and review manipulation.

The evidence indicates that materially different products are being grouped into the same variation families across multiple Amazon marketplaces, potentially allowing reviews and ratings from unrelated or older products to increase the apparent review history of newly launched listings.

I am surprised and concerned that no meaningful action appears to have been taken against the sellers reported.

This type of abuse can seriously damage legitimate sellers. A seller may spend five years building a product's sales history, customer trust, and reviews, only to see a competitor copy the product and obtain a comparable review count within weeks by linking, merging, or injecting older ASINs into complex variation structures.

In this case, we have identified what appears to be a complex cross-marketplace network involving Canada, Australia, Europe, and the United Kingdom that ultimately benefits newer listings in the United States. We are seeing materially different ASINs, older products, duplicated pack variations, and apparently unrelated listings being connected across marketplaces.

This does not appear to be an isolated listing error. The repeated structure and use of multiple marketplaces suggest a systematic strategy intended to transfer or aggregate review history around newer products.

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

Tags:Product reviews
30
29 views
3 replies
Reply
3 replies
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

please update

10
user profile
Manny_Amazon

Hello @Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa,

Amazon encourages sellers to report listing abuse or seller violations of Amazon's policies or applicable law. If you believe another seller is violating policies please follow the steps linked in "Report a Violation" through Seller Central.

All reports via this tool are thoroughly investigated by our partner team. Note that for reported Seller violations, our partner team reviews issues according to internal criteria and for security purposes does not have additional information to provide us regarding actions taken or not taken to address the violation.

Regards,

- Manny

10
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

Hi all,

75% of our reports were rejected, but it's very alarming to see our competitors using a digital thermometer, a basic door alarm, or a doorbell — products with a large number of reviews — listed as a child ASIN under a new parent ASIN related to a "fridge door alarm." This creates a very untrustworthy impression of the new product, and customers are being misled by this practice.

There are now two sellers using the same technique: they create an unrelated child ASIN with zero stock in the US, but keep it live in Canada, so it redirects to the parent ASIN — meaning no one can actually see the real "fake" ASIN. The same practice is happening in Europe with these same two sellers, and all our cases have been rejected.

The only marketplaces accepting our case are Canada and Australia — why do the other marketplaces refuse such an obvious case about an unrelated product hidden (zero stock) inside a promoted ASIN?

List of rejected cases:

Date Complaint ID Marketplace Violation

27 Aug 21772057841 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772089321 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21771926571 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772021441 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772173881 Canada Duplicate product listing

27 Aug 21772346481 Canada Duplicate product listing

27 Aug 13218632442 UK Duplicate product listing

29 Aug 13221713012 UK Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222881602 France Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222861192 Spain Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222917862 Germany Incorrect variation

02 Sep 21844243571 US Incorrect variation

02 Sep 21843836141 US Duplicate product listing

02 Sep 21843720751 US Duplicate product listing

Has anyone else dealt with this kind of hidden-child-ASIN abuse, and if so, how did you get it actioned? Any advice on how to escalate this beyond standard Report Abuse would be appreciated.

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

10
Follow this discussion to be notified of new activity
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

Cross-marketplace ASIN variations abuse and review manipulation

Dear Amazon Seller Support,

I am writing to follow up on Case ID 13183224902 and 13182321402 regarding suspected cross-marketplace ASIN variation abuse and review manipulation.

The evidence indicates that materially different products are being grouped into the same variation families across multiple Amazon marketplaces, potentially allowing reviews and ratings from unrelated or older products to increase the apparent review history of newly launched listings.

I am surprised and concerned that no meaningful action appears to have been taken against the sellers reported.

This type of abuse can seriously damage legitimate sellers. A seller may spend five years building a product's sales history, customer trust, and reviews, only to see a competitor copy the product and obtain a comparable review count within weeks by linking, merging, or injecting older ASINs into complex variation structures.

In this case, we have identified what appears to be a complex cross-marketplace network involving Canada, Australia, Europe, and the United Kingdom that ultimately benefits newer listings in the United States. We are seeing materially different ASINs, older products, duplicated pack variations, and apparently unrelated listings being connected across marketplaces.

This does not appear to be an isolated listing error. The repeated structure and use of multiple marketplaces suggest a systematic strategy intended to transfer or aggregate review history around newer products.

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

29 views
3 replies
Tags:Product reviews
30
Reply
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

Cross-marketplace ASIN variations abuse and review manipulation

Dear Amazon Seller Support,

I am writing to follow up on Case ID 13183224902 and 13182321402 regarding suspected cross-marketplace ASIN variation abuse and review manipulation.

The evidence indicates that materially different products are being grouped into the same variation families across multiple Amazon marketplaces, potentially allowing reviews and ratings from unrelated or older products to increase the apparent review history of newly launched listings.

I am surprised and concerned that no meaningful action appears to have been taken against the sellers reported.

This type of abuse can seriously damage legitimate sellers. A seller may spend five years building a product's sales history, customer trust, and reviews, only to see a competitor copy the product and obtain a comparable review count within weeks by linking, merging, or injecting older ASINs into complex variation structures.

In this case, we have identified what appears to be a complex cross-marketplace network involving Canada, Australia, Europe, and the United Kingdom that ultimately benefits newer listings in the United States. We are seeing materially different ASINs, older products, duplicated pack variations, and apparently unrelated listings being connected across marketplaces.

This does not appear to be an isolated listing error. The repeated structure and use of multiple marketplaces suggest a systematic strategy intended to transfer or aggregate review history around newer products.

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

Tags:Product reviews
30
29 views
3 replies
Reply
user profile

Cross-marketplace ASIN variations abuse and review manipulation

by Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

Dear Amazon Seller Support,

I am writing to follow up on Case ID 13183224902 and 13182321402 regarding suspected cross-marketplace ASIN variation abuse and review manipulation.

The evidence indicates that materially different products are being grouped into the same variation families across multiple Amazon marketplaces, potentially allowing reviews and ratings from unrelated or older products to increase the apparent review history of newly launched listings.

I am surprised and concerned that no meaningful action appears to have been taken against the sellers reported.

This type of abuse can seriously damage legitimate sellers. A seller may spend five years building a product's sales history, customer trust, and reviews, only to see a competitor copy the product and obtain a comparable review count within weeks by linking, merging, or injecting older ASINs into complex variation structures.

In this case, we have identified what appears to be a complex cross-marketplace network involving Canada, Australia, Europe, and the United Kingdom that ultimately benefits newer listings in the United States. We are seeing materially different ASINs, older products, duplicated pack variations, and apparently unrelated listings being connected across marketplaces.

This does not appear to be an isolated listing error. The repeated structure and use of multiple marketplaces suggest a systematic strategy intended to transfer or aggregate review history around newer products.

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

Tags:Product reviews
30
29 views
3 replies
Reply
3 replies
3 replies
Quick filters
Sort by
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

please update

10
user profile
Manny_Amazon

Hello @Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa,

Amazon encourages sellers to report listing abuse or seller violations of Amazon's policies or applicable law. If you believe another seller is violating policies please follow the steps linked in "Report a Violation" through Seller Central.

All reports via this tool are thoroughly investigated by our partner team. Note that for reported Seller violations, our partner team reviews issues according to internal criteria and for security purposes does not have additional information to provide us regarding actions taken or not taken to address the violation.

Regards,

- Manny

10
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

Hi all,

75% of our reports were rejected, but it's very alarming to see our competitors using a digital thermometer, a basic door alarm, or a doorbell — products with a large number of reviews — listed as a child ASIN under a new parent ASIN related to a "fridge door alarm." This creates a very untrustworthy impression of the new product, and customers are being misled by this practice.

There are now two sellers using the same technique: they create an unrelated child ASIN with zero stock in the US, but keep it live in Canada, so it redirects to the parent ASIN — meaning no one can actually see the real "fake" ASIN. The same practice is happening in Europe with these same two sellers, and all our cases have been rejected.

The only marketplaces accepting our case are Canada and Australia — why do the other marketplaces refuse such an obvious case about an unrelated product hidden (zero stock) inside a promoted ASIN?

List of rejected cases:

Date Complaint ID Marketplace Violation

27 Aug 21772057841 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772089321 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21771926571 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772021441 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772173881 Canada Duplicate product listing

27 Aug 21772346481 Canada Duplicate product listing

27 Aug 13218632442 UK Duplicate product listing

29 Aug 13221713012 UK Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222881602 France Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222861192 Spain Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222917862 Germany Incorrect variation

02 Sep 21844243571 US Incorrect variation

02 Sep 21843836141 US Duplicate product listing

02 Sep 21843720751 US Duplicate product listing

Has anyone else dealt with this kind of hidden-child-ASIN abuse, and if so, how did you get it actioned? Any advice on how to escalate this beyond standard Report Abuse would be appreciated.

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

10
Follow this discussion to be notified of new activity
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

please update

10
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

please update

10
Reply
user profile
Manny_Amazon

Hello @Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa,

Amazon encourages sellers to report listing abuse or seller violations of Amazon's policies or applicable law. If you believe another seller is violating policies please follow the steps linked in "Report a Violation" through Seller Central.

All reports via this tool are thoroughly investigated by our partner team. Note that for reported Seller violations, our partner team reviews issues according to internal criteria and for security purposes does not have additional information to provide us regarding actions taken or not taken to address the violation.

Regards,

- Manny

10
user profile
Manny_Amazon

Hello @Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa,

Amazon encourages sellers to report listing abuse or seller violations of Amazon's policies or applicable law. If you believe another seller is violating policies please follow the steps linked in "Report a Violation" through Seller Central.

All reports via this tool are thoroughly investigated by our partner team. Note that for reported Seller violations, our partner team reviews issues according to internal criteria and for security purposes does not have additional information to provide us regarding actions taken or not taken to address the violation.

Regards,

- Manny

10
Reply
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

Hi all,

75% of our reports were rejected, but it's very alarming to see our competitors using a digital thermometer, a basic door alarm, or a doorbell — products with a large number of reviews — listed as a child ASIN under a new parent ASIN related to a "fridge door alarm." This creates a very untrustworthy impression of the new product, and customers are being misled by this practice.

There are now two sellers using the same technique: they create an unrelated child ASIN with zero stock in the US, but keep it live in Canada, so it redirects to the parent ASIN — meaning no one can actually see the real "fake" ASIN. The same practice is happening in Europe with these same two sellers, and all our cases have been rejected.

The only marketplaces accepting our case are Canada and Australia — why do the other marketplaces refuse such an obvious case about an unrelated product hidden (zero stock) inside a promoted ASIN?

List of rejected cases:

Date Complaint ID Marketplace Violation

27 Aug 21772057841 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772089321 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21771926571 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772021441 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772173881 Canada Duplicate product listing

27 Aug 21772346481 Canada Duplicate product listing

27 Aug 13218632442 UK Duplicate product listing

29 Aug 13221713012 UK Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222881602 France Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222861192 Spain Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222917862 Germany Incorrect variation

02 Sep 21844243571 US Incorrect variation

02 Sep 21843836141 US Duplicate product listing

02 Sep 21843720751 US Duplicate product listing

Has anyone else dealt with this kind of hidden-child-ASIN abuse, and if so, how did you get it actioned? Any advice on how to escalate this beyond standard Report Abuse would be appreciated.

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

10
user profile
Seller_DoR5rFDShUxHa

Hi all,

75% of our reports were rejected, but it's very alarming to see our competitors using a digital thermometer, a basic door alarm, or a doorbell — products with a large number of reviews — listed as a child ASIN under a new parent ASIN related to a "fridge door alarm." This creates a very untrustworthy impression of the new product, and customers are being misled by this practice.

There are now two sellers using the same technique: they create an unrelated child ASIN with zero stock in the US, but keep it live in Canada, so it redirects to the parent ASIN — meaning no one can actually see the real "fake" ASIN. The same practice is happening in Europe with these same two sellers, and all our cases have been rejected.

The only marketplaces accepting our case are Canada and Australia — why do the other marketplaces refuse such an obvious case about an unrelated product hidden (zero stock) inside a promoted ASIN?

List of rejected cases:

Date Complaint ID Marketplace Violation

27 Aug 21772057841 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772089321 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21771926571 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772021441 US Listing changed to represent a different product

27 Aug 21772173881 Canada Duplicate product listing

27 Aug 21772346481 Canada Duplicate product listing

27 Aug 13218632442 UK Duplicate product listing

29 Aug 13221713012 UK Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222881602 France Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222861192 Spain Incorrect variation

29 Aug 13222917862 Germany Incorrect variation

02 Sep 21844243571 US Incorrect variation

02 Sep 21843836141 US Duplicate product listing

02 Sep 21843720751 US Duplicate product listing

Has anyone else dealt with this kind of hidden-child-ASIN abuse, and if so, how did you get it actioned? Any advice on how to escalate this beyond standard Report Abuse would be appreciated.

@Michelle_Amazon @Manny_Amazon @Dougal_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Topher_Amazon @Sandy_Amazon @Bryce_Amazon @TaylorR_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Kai_Amazon

10
Reply
Follow this discussion to be notified of new activity