Customer has clearly damaged the item themselves and are claiming an a to z claim
Dear Amazon Customer Service Team,
We are writing regarding the A-to-Z Guarantee claim raised by the customer.
The customer originally purchased this item from us. Due to the ordered colour being out of stock, we contacted the customer and offered an alternative colour. The customer agreed to the alternative colour, and we proceeded with the delivery.
After receiving the item, the customer damaged one of the panels while attempting to assemble the product. When the customer informed us of the issue, we explained that if a part appeared to be damaged, they should not have continued with the assembly. Nevertheless, we were willing to assist and offered to send a replacement part to resolve the issue.
However, instead of allowing us to resolve the matter, the customer subsequently opened an A-to-Z claim stating that the item had not been delivered.
We provided Amazon with proof of delivery, along with our complete correspondence with the customer, which confirms that the customer had received the item and had contacted us after delivery regarding the damaged panel and replacement part.
Despite the evidence provided, the claim was refunded to the customer. We respectfully wish to highlight that the customer has received the refund while the item itself remains in the customer's possession.
We kindly ask Amazon to review the proof of delivery and our correspondence with the customer again, as the evidence confirms that the order was delivered and that the customer had subsequently discussed the condition and assembly of the item with us.
We would appreciate Amazon reviewing the matter and considering the fact that the customer has both the item and the refund.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Kind regards,
Urban Furnishing Support Team
Customer has clearly damaged the item themselves and are claiming an a to z claim
Dear Amazon Customer Service Team,
We are writing regarding the A-to-Z Guarantee claim raised by the customer.
The customer originally purchased this item from us. Due to the ordered colour being out of stock, we contacted the customer and offered an alternative colour. The customer agreed to the alternative colour, and we proceeded with the delivery.
After receiving the item, the customer damaged one of the panels while attempting to assemble the product. When the customer informed us of the issue, we explained that if a part appeared to be damaged, they should not have continued with the assembly. Nevertheless, we were willing to assist and offered to send a replacement part to resolve the issue.
However, instead of allowing us to resolve the matter, the customer subsequently opened an A-to-Z claim stating that the item had not been delivered.
We provided Amazon with proof of delivery, along with our complete correspondence with the customer, which confirms that the customer had received the item and had contacted us after delivery regarding the damaged panel and replacement part.
Despite the evidence provided, the claim was refunded to the customer. We respectfully wish to highlight that the customer has received the refund while the item itself remains in the customer's possession.
We kindly ask Amazon to review the proof of delivery and our correspondence with the customer again, as the evidence confirms that the order was delivered and that the customer had subsequently discussed the condition and assembly of the item with us.
We would appreciate Amazon reviewing the matter and considering the fact that the customer has both the item and the refund.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Kind regards,
Urban Furnishing Support Team
0 replies
Seller_d8YGbIjNqwFxn
Did you appeal the item with a screenshot showing that the customer confirmed delivery? That would be the first step if you haven't done so far.
Seller_sSxf9ltVoIMz9
Did you send the product with a Signed-for service. If you didn't get a signature you lose, and no amount of delivery pictures, pictures of the customer using the product, messages from the customer saying they received it etc etc will, in my experience, make any difference
Ken_Amazon
Hi @Seller_DrFGGJ2znmIVI,
Thank you for posting.
If you haven't already, the most important next step is to file an appeal directly through your Seller Central account. You have 30 calendar days from the date the claim was granted to submit an appeal.
Important tip:
- The appeal text box does not support attachments. If you need to attach documents such as signature from the customer (proof of delivery), use Buyer-Seller Messages to send them, and then reference those attachments in your appeal response.
As @Seller_sSxf9ltVoIMz9 shared in their comment, for "Not Received" claims, the single most critical piece of evidence you need is a signed Proof of Delivery (POD) — specifically, a customer signature confirming receipt. Without a signature from the buyer matching their name, it is extremely difficult to overturn a Not Received claim, regardless of what other evidence you may have.
That being said, I still do want to look at the details of this A to Z Claim. Please share us the Order ID so that a Community Manager can look into your issue.
Best Regards,
Ken