A-to-Z Claims for Delivered Orders – How Are Other Sellers Dealing With This?
Hello everyone,
I'm interested to hear how other sellers are handling situations where an order is clearly marked as delivered, yet an A-to-Z claim is still granted to the buyer and refunded from the seller's account.
In our recent case:
The order was dispatched on time using a fully tracked service. - Royal mail - PF48
Tracking showed the parcel was delivered to the exact address provided by the customer.
The carrier provided:
Delivery confirmation
Signature
Delivery photograph
Confirmation of the person who accepted the parcel
We responded promptly to the customer and provided all tracking information.
Despite this, the customer opened an A-to-Z claim stating that the parcel had not been received.
Amazon's decision stated that:
The tracking confirms delivery.
The claim would not affect our Order Defect Rate because valid tracking was used.
However, the customer was still refunded and the amount was debited from our seller account.
This leaves me wondering:
How often are you seeing A-to-Z claims granted when tracking clearly shows delivery?
Do you appeal these decisions?
Are appeals successful when you have:
Signature
Photograph
GPS-tracked delivery
Delivery scan
Is this simply becoming a cost of doing business on Amazon?
Do sellers who use Royal Mail, Parcelforce, DPD, Evri, or Amazon Shipping see different outcomes?
Has anyone successfully recovered funds through a SAFE-T claim or appeal in similar circumstances? - we are here 15 years never - successfully recovered funds through a SAFE-T
I completely understand that Amazon wants to protect customers, and that's important for the marketplace.
However, it feels difficult when:
Sellers ship on time.
Sellers purchase tracked delivery.
Carriers confirm delivery.
Sellers respond to customer enquiries.
Yet the financial responsibility still appears to fall on the seller, even when there is strong proof that the parcel reached the delivery address provided by the customer.
I'm interested to know whether other sellers are experiencing an increase in these cases and what processes you have put in place to protect your business.
Are there particular carriers, shipping methods, or appeal strategies that seem to work better?
I'd appreciate hearing your experiences and any advice.
Thank you.
A-to-Z Claims for Delivered Orders – How Are Other Sellers Dealing With This?
Hello everyone,
I'm interested to hear how other sellers are handling situations where an order is clearly marked as delivered, yet an A-to-Z claim is still granted to the buyer and refunded from the seller's account.
In our recent case:
The order was dispatched on time using a fully tracked service. - Royal mail - PF48
Tracking showed the parcel was delivered to the exact address provided by the customer.
The carrier provided:
Delivery confirmation
Signature
Delivery photograph
Confirmation of the person who accepted the parcel
We responded promptly to the customer and provided all tracking information.
Despite this, the customer opened an A-to-Z claim stating that the parcel had not been received.
Amazon's decision stated that:
The tracking confirms delivery.
The claim would not affect our Order Defect Rate because valid tracking was used.
However, the customer was still refunded and the amount was debited from our seller account.
This leaves me wondering:
How often are you seeing A-to-Z claims granted when tracking clearly shows delivery?
Do you appeal these decisions?
Are appeals successful when you have:
Signature
Photograph
GPS-tracked delivery
Delivery scan
Is this simply becoming a cost of doing business on Amazon?
Do sellers who use Royal Mail, Parcelforce, DPD, Evri, or Amazon Shipping see different outcomes?
Has anyone successfully recovered funds through a SAFE-T claim or appeal in similar circumstances? - we are here 15 years never - successfully recovered funds through a SAFE-T
I completely understand that Amazon wants to protect customers, and that's important for the marketplace.
However, it feels difficult when:
Sellers ship on time.
Sellers purchase tracked delivery.
Carriers confirm delivery.
Sellers respond to customer enquiries.
Yet the financial responsibility still appears to fall on the seller, even when there is strong proof that the parcel reached the delivery address provided by the customer.
I'm interested to know whether other sellers are experiencing an increase in these cases and what processes you have put in place to protect your business.
Are there particular carriers, shipping methods, or appeal strategies that seem to work better?
I'd appreciate hearing your experiences and any advice.
Thank you.
9 replies
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh
This is easy for me to say as I'm not in your position, but these orders where Amazon state, in writing, they can see the order has been delivered yet still refund, should go to LBA and if no resolution Small Claims Court.
Seller_fLJ3Hdgrt17Ze
Hi @Amazon Moderators,
I would genuinely appreciate some clarification on Amazon's current position regarding A-to-z claims for delivered orders.
We recently had an A-to-z claim for Order 202-3859702-6387535, and our latest support case reference is:
Case ID: 13320647082
The order was:
Dispatched on time.
Sent using a fully tracked service.
Delivered to the exact address provided by the customer.
Tracking showed successful delivery.
Delivery confirmation was available.
A delivery photograph was available.
We responded promptly to the customer.
However, after multiple appeals, Amazon's final response stated:
"We have reviewed all of the available information and determined that you have not provided sufficient evidence to prove delivery."
What confuses me is that Amazon has not explained what evidence was missing.
As sellers, we would genuinely like to understand:
If valid tracking, delivery confirmation, and carrier proof of delivery are no longer considered sufficient evidence, what exactly does Amazon now require?
Has there been any recent change to A-to-z claim policy or evidence requirements?
What additional documentation should sellers obtain from carriers to successfully defend these claims?
If a tracked parcel delivered to the customer's address is still considered insufficient evidence, what practical steps can sellers take to protect themselves?
Are there specific carrier services Amazon considers acceptable for proof of delivery and others that are not?
I am not asking for the claim decision to be overturned via the forum. I am trying to understand what Amazon expects from sellers so that we can comply with the requirements in future cases.
Many sellers invest in tracked delivery specifically because we believe it provides protection in the event of a non-receipt claim. When an appeal is rejected despite delivery confirmation, a delivery photograph, and carrier records confirming successful delivery, sellers need to understand what additional evidence Amazon expects.
I would appreciate any guidance from the moderation team and clarification on whether there have been any recent changes to the evaluation criteria for A-to-z claims.
Thank you.
{Moderator Edit - removed personally identifiable information - please refrain from posting personal data}
Seller_fLJ3Hdgrt17Ze
Hi @Amazon Moderators,
@Susi_Amazon @Joey_Amazon @Sakura_Amazon__ @Manny_Amazon @Cooper_Amazon @Xander_Amazon @Simon_Amazon @Indy_Amazon @Aria_Amazon @Ken_Amazon
I would genuinely appreciate some clarification on Amazon's current position regarding A-to-z claims for delivered orders.
Kam_Amazon
@Seller_fLJ3Hdgrt17Ze, we appreciate you sharing all of this detail and we understand this is a difficult outcome to process, especially when you have invested in a premium delivery service.
When Amazon evaluates an A-to-Z claim for "Item Not Received," the outcome is based on the delivery evidence available through the tracking information associated with the order. Services that rely on alternative delivery acceptance, such as neighbour or safe place delivery, may not carry the same weight during the review process.
Going forward, Amazon's Buy Shipping services, when available in your marketplace, can provide an added layer of protection on claims by giving Amazon direct visibility into the shipping and delivery data. You may also want to explore carrier options that offer direct-to-recipient confirmation or one-time passcode verification on delivery. These methods help ensure that proof of delivery aligns with what Amazon's systems can verify. If you have any further questions about protecting yourself going forward, we are happy to help!
Seller_fLJ3Hdgrt17Ze
Hi @Kam_Amazon,
Thank you for your response.
Just to clarify, are you saying that if a customer places an order on Amazon, and the parcel is delivered to the address provided on the order, with photographic proof of delivery and a signature obtained at the delivery address by Royal Mail or Parcelforce, the customer could still file an A-to-z claim and potentially receive a refund?
Is that Amazon's official policy?
If so, what level of delivery evidence is considered sufficient to protect a seller when using a third-party carrier rather than Amazon Buy Shipping?
I have been selling on Amazon for over 15 years, and I find it difficult to believe that photographic proof of delivery and a signature at the delivery address would not carry significant weight when reviewing an "Item Not Received" claim simply because Amazon Buy Shipping was not used.
I would appreciate clarification on Amazon's official policy regarding this point.
Thank you.
Seller_ZQyopdiwkUHOZ
I just hope we won't get too many of them because at our price and profit margin, they're simply not worth the time (or mental damage) to fight them.
If you're having multiple orders of that value, then you could absolutely compile multiple wrongly awarded atoz claims together and think about small claims court.
Seller_d8YGbIjNqwFxn
Amazon policy and Mods continually say that a signature confirmation is often needed in addition to what you quoted to prove delivery. Although this is contradicted by sellers who post on here to say A-Z's are rewarded even when there is a signature confirmation
There is nothing that will guarantee you to win an A-Z claim, in my experience fully tracked helps deter customers from making claims but the odd one still will and will win.
Seller_fLJ3Hdgrt17Ze
Hi Ken,
Thank you for your response.
I understand your point regarding signatures. However, I am struggling to understand what more a seller can reasonably do in this situation.
In this case:
The parcel was delivered to the exact delivery address provided by the buyer.
The parcel was not left unattended.
The carrier provided delivery confirmation and proof of delivery.
The parcel was accepted at the delivery address.
As a seller, we have no control over who answers the door or who signs for a parcel at the buyer's address. We cannot instruct the carrier to accept a signature only from the exact named individual on the order.
Is there now a requirement that the person signing must exactly match the buyer's name on the order?
If a spouse, family member, reception staff member, colleague, or another person at the delivery address accepts the parcel, does Amazon automatically consider this insufficient proof of delivery?
I am genuinely trying to understand Amazon's expectations because the carrier delivered to the address supplied by the buyer and obtained a signature at that location.
Also, regarding the forum thread, my intention was simply to share a similar experience and seek clarification about Amazon's current evidential requirements for delivered orders. I was not attempting to raise an unrelated issue.
Thank you for any clarification you can provide.
