Seller Forums
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Second hand Books gating & requiring approval

Hi,

Just wondering if anyone else as noticed lately when sourcing books quite a few seem to be gated these days and requiring an invoice?

I’ve been sourcing books over the past few weeks and I’m noticing that quite a few books when I try scan them in the publisher/brand is gated. Never known it to be this bad

Any thoughts on this?

Thanks

396 views
180 replies
Tags:Restricted Products
00
Reply
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Second hand Books gating & requiring approval

Hi,

Just wondering if anyone else as noticed lately when sourcing books quite a few seem to be gated these days and requiring an invoice?

I’ve been sourcing books over the past few weeks and I’m noticing that quite a few books when I try scan them in the publisher/brand is gated. Never known it to be this bad

Any thoughts on this?

Thanks

Tags:Restricted Products
00
396 views
180 replies
Reply
180 replies
user profile
Seller_LpjhinHAD7f55

Hi this has been happening for months with certain publishers and as with second hand books your not going to have an invoice which is required to sell the book

30
user profile
Seller_AlYpsVHv0gj21

There must be at least 10 threads currently on this subject. It has been going on for quite a few years.

Various mods have come on this board promising help but nothing ever seems to be done.

I think it is scandalous.

If you add on the other issue of suspending book listings because they are "priced too high" there must be hundreds of thousands of books in total suspended for no good reason.

@michelle_

50
user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

I honestly now believe this is an In House problem

whether by design or accident it is just being ignored

Yet some sellers can list without any problems !

30
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Hi Brian,

Hope your'e well.

I've had this exact issue today that I was fearing would happen. So I listed 2 books in the past week or so, no problem when listing and not needing approval (Even though books shouldn't need approval).

I've then woke up to an email from Amazon this morning stating the 2 books have been removed from my inventory due to needing approval. 2 Different publishers Bloomsbury & Mariner Books.

Its becoming impossible now, its bad enough when your sourcing books that you need approval, but now books/Stock I've already bought and listed succesfully being removed. Money thrown away. Its making me seriously considering giving up now, can't even buy stock in the confidence that it wont removed in a weeks time.

Fight an impossible battle due to Amazons lack of understanding and acknowledgment to this issue

20
user profile
TaylorR_Amazon

Hello all, I have heard from the team and they confirmed this is a pain-point they are aware of and they are working to ease for sellers.

As our catalogue grows, we continuously make new determinations for which products should be restricted based on a number of factors. Even if you were selling your product before, you may be subject to new restrictions for the following reasons:

  • Amazon has placed new restrictions on existing products that either require you to qualify or that Amazon is not accepting the applications currently.
  • You have received a performance notification related to your product and are required to provide additional information before you can sell it again. You can view these notifications through your Performance Notifications or your Account health page.

Selling Applications FAQ

02
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

@Seller_ZVAz3d5lZuGid@Seller_AlYpsVHv0gj21@Seller_f9qmYtHo6NHQv@Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW@Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh@Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

00
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi TaylorR_Amazon,

Please may I attempt to summarise:

First Sale Doctrine allows us legally to sell a previously bought book.

Amazon determines what may be sold on their site:

If Amazon has reached an agreement with a publisher this may restrict all books with that publisher's imprint (or previously assimilated ones), specific author's books or specific titles. Older editions of books may also be restricted.

These restrictions may be achieved by the removal of the Detail Pages, or by requiring approval through request or provision of recent invoices

If a book has been restricted (but the Detail Page has not been removed), the restrictions apply to newly listed items, but existing offering may be allowed to continue

With the latter items, as the lower-cost offerings sell, the ones remaining will logically be the higher priced ones...

Hope that helps

All Best

Brian

00
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Morning Brian,

Just makes no sense at all that response from @TaylorR_Amazondoes it? And doesnt actually give an answer as to how the whole issue is going to be solved.

Like youve just mentioned about the first sale doctrine again, it’s clearly being ignored by Amazon and surely there cant be all these publishers coming out and saying they don’t want sellers selling their books because you can still sell them on other platforms without issue. Just doesn’t make sense.

10
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi LIAMTORetail,

Amazon lists new books for sale and it's possible that some publishers don't want used copies of earlier editions of their books competing... which could explain why other sites are less restrictive

Or perhaps there are legal reasons e.g. author moving to a new publisher and insisting that their name not be linked?

Who knows... but it's Amazon's site and we have to play by their rules

All Best

Brian

00
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Yeah I guess that’s true

It just feels like a game of cat and mouse now. You list a book no issues then it could be removed within days due to needing approval. You can’t list anything with confidence now.

It’s going to become impossible eventually the way things are going

10
user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

Sorry but it doesn't address why books now have new branded identities that do not relate in any way to the publishers

Yes it's Amazons web site so they can make their own rules But, that should not go against a point of recognised law unless they make it very very clear they are not following First Sale Doctrine. Which is also recognised in law where the company was set up !

20
user profile
Seller_ZVAz3d5lZuGid

@Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn - totally agree. Have you been following the other long thread about the issue ?

This one :

https://sellercentral.amazon.co.uk/seller-forums/discussions/t/74a0a58e-9813-49ef-9cfb-5f1a74ad3c0d?

I posted earlier tagging in the mods who responded, but how, why can Amazon just totally ignore the doctrine ??

20
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Are we talking about the word branded after the publishers name? Completely agree they are publishers not brands, I’ve noticed it’s happening quite a lot on here that. Finding loads lately with the word branded at the end of their names.

I dunno about you but from the MOD response I can’t see this situation improving at all. Feels to me now like a game of cat and mouse, you list a book and see how long it takes for it to be removed pending approval. No confidence at all anymore selling books on here

End of the day they make us sellers jump through hoops when it comes to compliance but yet for them compliance with first sale doctrine doesnt count by the look of it.

20
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi JillyB,

Things may be legally for sale in the UK but you might not want them on your site, for whatever reason: they might be politically or sexually offensive, in a pharmaseutical grey area or even dangerous...

Where I have difficulty is the removal of items due to potential uncompetitive pricing, when others are allowed to ask higher prices without being banned...

All Best

Brian

10
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

Just had A&C Black added to the publishers I have to apply for.

Ho-hum, will take my £85 very sellable title and sell elsewhere.

20
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

Then do something about it.

Put your time in to selling elsewhere instead of continually flogging the dead horse that is Amazon.

user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN
Complete waste of time now bookselling on here and constant battle that’s only going to get worse sooner rather later
View post
10
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

I would bet an awful lot the publishers have every knowledge and are in collusion with Amazon restricting listings, as it's them that benefit by buyers not being able to buy used copies and forced to buy new copies.

user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn
I doubt they have any idea the bots are closing your listings
View post
10
Follow this discussion to be notified of new activity
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Second hand Books gating & requiring approval

Hi,

Just wondering if anyone else as noticed lately when sourcing books quite a few seem to be gated these days and requiring an invoice?

I’ve been sourcing books over the past few weeks and I’m noticing that quite a few books when I try scan them in the publisher/brand is gated. Never known it to be this bad

Any thoughts on this?

Thanks

396 views
180 replies
Tags:Restricted Products
00
Reply
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Second hand Books gating & requiring approval

Hi,

Just wondering if anyone else as noticed lately when sourcing books quite a few seem to be gated these days and requiring an invoice?

I’ve been sourcing books over the past few weeks and I’m noticing that quite a few books when I try scan them in the publisher/brand is gated. Never known it to be this bad

Any thoughts on this?

Thanks

Tags:Restricted Products
00
396 views
180 replies
Reply
user profile

Second hand Books gating & requiring approval

by Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Hi,

Just wondering if anyone else as noticed lately when sourcing books quite a few seem to be gated these days and requiring an invoice?

I’ve been sourcing books over the past few weeks and I’m noticing that quite a few books when I try scan them in the publisher/brand is gated. Never known it to be this bad

Any thoughts on this?

Thanks

Tags:Restricted Products
00
396 views
180 replies
Reply
180 replies
180 replies
Quick filters
Sort by
user profile
Seller_LpjhinHAD7f55

Hi this has been happening for months with certain publishers and as with second hand books your not going to have an invoice which is required to sell the book

30
user profile
Seller_AlYpsVHv0gj21

There must be at least 10 threads currently on this subject. It has been going on for quite a few years.

Various mods have come on this board promising help but nothing ever seems to be done.

I think it is scandalous.

If you add on the other issue of suspending book listings because they are "priced too high" there must be hundreds of thousands of books in total suspended for no good reason.

@michelle_

50
user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

I honestly now believe this is an In House problem

whether by design or accident it is just being ignored

Yet some sellers can list without any problems !

30
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Hi Brian,

Hope your'e well.

I've had this exact issue today that I was fearing would happen. So I listed 2 books in the past week or so, no problem when listing and not needing approval (Even though books shouldn't need approval).

I've then woke up to an email from Amazon this morning stating the 2 books have been removed from my inventory due to needing approval. 2 Different publishers Bloomsbury & Mariner Books.

Its becoming impossible now, its bad enough when your sourcing books that you need approval, but now books/Stock I've already bought and listed succesfully being removed. Money thrown away. Its making me seriously considering giving up now, can't even buy stock in the confidence that it wont removed in a weeks time.

Fight an impossible battle due to Amazons lack of understanding and acknowledgment to this issue

20
user profile
TaylorR_Amazon

Hello all, I have heard from the team and they confirmed this is a pain-point they are aware of and they are working to ease for sellers.

As our catalogue grows, we continuously make new determinations for which products should be restricted based on a number of factors. Even if you were selling your product before, you may be subject to new restrictions for the following reasons:

  • Amazon has placed new restrictions on existing products that either require you to qualify or that Amazon is not accepting the applications currently.
  • You have received a performance notification related to your product and are required to provide additional information before you can sell it again. You can view these notifications through your Performance Notifications or your Account health page.

Selling Applications FAQ

02
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

@Seller_ZVAz3d5lZuGid@Seller_AlYpsVHv0gj21@Seller_f9qmYtHo6NHQv@Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW@Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh@Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

00
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi TaylorR_Amazon,

Please may I attempt to summarise:

First Sale Doctrine allows us legally to sell a previously bought book.

Amazon determines what may be sold on their site:

If Amazon has reached an agreement with a publisher this may restrict all books with that publisher's imprint (or previously assimilated ones), specific author's books or specific titles. Older editions of books may also be restricted.

These restrictions may be achieved by the removal of the Detail Pages, or by requiring approval through request or provision of recent invoices

If a book has been restricted (but the Detail Page has not been removed), the restrictions apply to newly listed items, but existing offering may be allowed to continue

With the latter items, as the lower-cost offerings sell, the ones remaining will logically be the higher priced ones...

Hope that helps

All Best

Brian

00
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Morning Brian,

Just makes no sense at all that response from @TaylorR_Amazondoes it? And doesnt actually give an answer as to how the whole issue is going to be solved.

Like youve just mentioned about the first sale doctrine again, it’s clearly being ignored by Amazon and surely there cant be all these publishers coming out and saying they don’t want sellers selling their books because you can still sell them on other platforms without issue. Just doesn’t make sense.

10
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi LIAMTORetail,

Amazon lists new books for sale and it's possible that some publishers don't want used copies of earlier editions of their books competing... which could explain why other sites are less restrictive

Or perhaps there are legal reasons e.g. author moving to a new publisher and insisting that their name not be linked?

Who knows... but it's Amazon's site and we have to play by their rules

All Best

Brian

00
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Yeah I guess that’s true

It just feels like a game of cat and mouse now. You list a book no issues then it could be removed within days due to needing approval. You can’t list anything with confidence now.

It’s going to become impossible eventually the way things are going

10
user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

Sorry but it doesn't address why books now have new branded identities that do not relate in any way to the publishers

Yes it's Amazons web site so they can make their own rules But, that should not go against a point of recognised law unless they make it very very clear they are not following First Sale Doctrine. Which is also recognised in law where the company was set up !

20
user profile
Seller_ZVAz3d5lZuGid

@Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn - totally agree. Have you been following the other long thread about the issue ?

This one :

https://sellercentral.amazon.co.uk/seller-forums/discussions/t/74a0a58e-9813-49ef-9cfb-5f1a74ad3c0d?

I posted earlier tagging in the mods who responded, but how, why can Amazon just totally ignore the doctrine ??

20
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Are we talking about the word branded after the publishers name? Completely agree they are publishers not brands, I’ve noticed it’s happening quite a lot on here that. Finding loads lately with the word branded at the end of their names.

I dunno about you but from the MOD response I can’t see this situation improving at all. Feels to me now like a game of cat and mouse, you list a book and see how long it takes for it to be removed pending approval. No confidence at all anymore selling books on here

End of the day they make us sellers jump through hoops when it comes to compliance but yet for them compliance with first sale doctrine doesnt count by the look of it.

20
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi JillyB,

Things may be legally for sale in the UK but you might not want them on your site, for whatever reason: they might be politically or sexually offensive, in a pharmaseutical grey area or even dangerous...

Where I have difficulty is the removal of items due to potential uncompetitive pricing, when others are allowed to ask higher prices without being banned...

All Best

Brian

10
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

Just had A&C Black added to the publishers I have to apply for.

Ho-hum, will take my £85 very sellable title and sell elsewhere.

20
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

Then do something about it.

Put your time in to selling elsewhere instead of continually flogging the dead horse that is Amazon.

user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN
Complete waste of time now bookselling on here and constant battle that’s only going to get worse sooner rather later
View post
10
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

I would bet an awful lot the publishers have every knowledge and are in collusion with Amazon restricting listings, as it's them that benefit by buyers not being able to buy used copies and forced to buy new copies.

user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn
I doubt they have any idea the bots are closing your listings
View post
10
Follow this discussion to be notified of new activity
user profile
Seller_LpjhinHAD7f55

Hi this has been happening for months with certain publishers and as with second hand books your not going to have an invoice which is required to sell the book

30
user profile
Seller_LpjhinHAD7f55

Hi this has been happening for months with certain publishers and as with second hand books your not going to have an invoice which is required to sell the book

30
Reply
user profile
Seller_AlYpsVHv0gj21

There must be at least 10 threads currently on this subject. It has been going on for quite a few years.

Various mods have come on this board promising help but nothing ever seems to be done.

I think it is scandalous.

If you add on the other issue of suspending book listings because they are "priced too high" there must be hundreds of thousands of books in total suspended for no good reason.

@michelle_

50
user profile
Seller_AlYpsVHv0gj21

There must be at least 10 threads currently on this subject. It has been going on for quite a few years.

Various mods have come on this board promising help but nothing ever seems to be done.

I think it is scandalous.

If you add on the other issue of suspending book listings because they are "priced too high" there must be hundreds of thousands of books in total suspended for no good reason.

@michelle_

50
Reply
user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

I honestly now believe this is an In House problem

whether by design or accident it is just being ignored

Yet some sellers can list without any problems !

30
user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

I honestly now believe this is an In House problem

whether by design or accident it is just being ignored

Yet some sellers can list without any problems !

30
Reply
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Hi Brian,

Hope your'e well.

I've had this exact issue today that I was fearing would happen. So I listed 2 books in the past week or so, no problem when listing and not needing approval (Even though books shouldn't need approval).

I've then woke up to an email from Amazon this morning stating the 2 books have been removed from my inventory due to needing approval. 2 Different publishers Bloomsbury & Mariner Books.

Its becoming impossible now, its bad enough when your sourcing books that you need approval, but now books/Stock I've already bought and listed succesfully being removed. Money thrown away. Its making me seriously considering giving up now, can't even buy stock in the confidence that it wont removed in a weeks time.

Fight an impossible battle due to Amazons lack of understanding and acknowledgment to this issue

20
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Hi Brian,

Hope your'e well.

I've had this exact issue today that I was fearing would happen. So I listed 2 books in the past week or so, no problem when listing and not needing approval (Even though books shouldn't need approval).

I've then woke up to an email from Amazon this morning stating the 2 books have been removed from my inventory due to needing approval. 2 Different publishers Bloomsbury & Mariner Books.

Its becoming impossible now, its bad enough when your sourcing books that you need approval, but now books/Stock I've already bought and listed succesfully being removed. Money thrown away. Its making me seriously considering giving up now, can't even buy stock in the confidence that it wont removed in a weeks time.

Fight an impossible battle due to Amazons lack of understanding and acknowledgment to this issue

20
Reply
user profile
TaylorR_Amazon

Hello all, I have heard from the team and they confirmed this is a pain-point they are aware of and they are working to ease for sellers.

As our catalogue grows, we continuously make new determinations for which products should be restricted based on a number of factors. Even if you were selling your product before, you may be subject to new restrictions for the following reasons:

  • Amazon has placed new restrictions on existing products that either require you to qualify or that Amazon is not accepting the applications currently.
  • You have received a performance notification related to your product and are required to provide additional information before you can sell it again. You can view these notifications through your Performance Notifications or your Account health page.

Selling Applications FAQ

02
user profile
TaylorR_Amazon

Hello all, I have heard from the team and they confirmed this is a pain-point they are aware of and they are working to ease for sellers.

As our catalogue grows, we continuously make new determinations for which products should be restricted based on a number of factors. Even if you were selling your product before, you may be subject to new restrictions for the following reasons:

  • Amazon has placed new restrictions on existing products that either require you to qualify or that Amazon is not accepting the applications currently.
  • You have received a performance notification related to your product and are required to provide additional information before you can sell it again. You can view these notifications through your Performance Notifications or your Account health page.

Selling Applications FAQ

02
Reply
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

@Seller_ZVAz3d5lZuGid@Seller_AlYpsVHv0gj21@Seller_f9qmYtHo6NHQv@Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW@Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh@Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

00
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

@Seller_ZVAz3d5lZuGid@Seller_AlYpsVHv0gj21@Seller_f9qmYtHo6NHQv@Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW@Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh@Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

00
Reply
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi TaylorR_Amazon,

Please may I attempt to summarise:

First Sale Doctrine allows us legally to sell a previously bought book.

Amazon determines what may be sold on their site:

If Amazon has reached an agreement with a publisher this may restrict all books with that publisher's imprint (or previously assimilated ones), specific author's books or specific titles. Older editions of books may also be restricted.

These restrictions may be achieved by the removal of the Detail Pages, or by requiring approval through request or provision of recent invoices

If a book has been restricted (but the Detail Page has not been removed), the restrictions apply to newly listed items, but existing offering may be allowed to continue

With the latter items, as the lower-cost offerings sell, the ones remaining will logically be the higher priced ones...

Hope that helps

All Best

Brian

00
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi TaylorR_Amazon,

Please may I attempt to summarise:

First Sale Doctrine allows us legally to sell a previously bought book.

Amazon determines what may be sold on their site:

If Amazon has reached an agreement with a publisher this may restrict all books with that publisher's imprint (or previously assimilated ones), specific author's books or specific titles. Older editions of books may also be restricted.

These restrictions may be achieved by the removal of the Detail Pages, or by requiring approval through request or provision of recent invoices

If a book has been restricted (but the Detail Page has not been removed), the restrictions apply to newly listed items, but existing offering may be allowed to continue

With the latter items, as the lower-cost offerings sell, the ones remaining will logically be the higher priced ones...

Hope that helps

All Best

Brian

00
Reply
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Morning Brian,

Just makes no sense at all that response from @TaylorR_Amazondoes it? And doesnt actually give an answer as to how the whole issue is going to be solved.

Like youve just mentioned about the first sale doctrine again, it’s clearly being ignored by Amazon and surely there cant be all these publishers coming out and saying they don’t want sellers selling their books because you can still sell them on other platforms without issue. Just doesn’t make sense.

10
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Morning Brian,

Just makes no sense at all that response from @TaylorR_Amazondoes it? And doesnt actually give an answer as to how the whole issue is going to be solved.

Like youve just mentioned about the first sale doctrine again, it’s clearly being ignored by Amazon and surely there cant be all these publishers coming out and saying they don’t want sellers selling their books because you can still sell them on other platforms without issue. Just doesn’t make sense.

10
Reply
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi LIAMTORetail,

Amazon lists new books for sale and it's possible that some publishers don't want used copies of earlier editions of their books competing... which could explain why other sites are less restrictive

Or perhaps there are legal reasons e.g. author moving to a new publisher and insisting that their name not be linked?

Who knows... but it's Amazon's site and we have to play by their rules

All Best

Brian

00
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi LIAMTORetail,

Amazon lists new books for sale and it's possible that some publishers don't want used copies of earlier editions of their books competing... which could explain why other sites are less restrictive

Or perhaps there are legal reasons e.g. author moving to a new publisher and insisting that their name not be linked?

Who knows... but it's Amazon's site and we have to play by their rules

All Best

Brian

00
Reply
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Yeah I guess that’s true

It just feels like a game of cat and mouse now. You list a book no issues then it could be removed within days due to needing approval. You can’t list anything with confidence now.

It’s going to become impossible eventually the way things are going

10
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Yeah I guess that’s true

It just feels like a game of cat and mouse now. You list a book no issues then it could be removed within days due to needing approval. You can’t list anything with confidence now.

It’s going to become impossible eventually the way things are going

10
Reply
user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

Sorry but it doesn't address why books now have new branded identities that do not relate in any way to the publishers

Yes it's Amazons web site so they can make their own rules But, that should not go against a point of recognised law unless they make it very very clear they are not following First Sale Doctrine. Which is also recognised in law where the company was set up !

20
user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn

Sorry but it doesn't address why books now have new branded identities that do not relate in any way to the publishers

Yes it's Amazons web site so they can make their own rules But, that should not go against a point of recognised law unless they make it very very clear they are not following First Sale Doctrine. Which is also recognised in law where the company was set up !

20
Reply
user profile
Seller_ZVAz3d5lZuGid

@Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn - totally agree. Have you been following the other long thread about the issue ?

This one :

https://sellercentral.amazon.co.uk/seller-forums/discussions/t/74a0a58e-9813-49ef-9cfb-5f1a74ad3c0d?

I posted earlier tagging in the mods who responded, but how, why can Amazon just totally ignore the doctrine ??

20
user profile
Seller_ZVAz3d5lZuGid

@Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn - totally agree. Have you been following the other long thread about the issue ?

This one :

https://sellercentral.amazon.co.uk/seller-forums/discussions/t/74a0a58e-9813-49ef-9cfb-5f1a74ad3c0d?

I posted earlier tagging in the mods who responded, but how, why can Amazon just totally ignore the doctrine ??

20
Reply
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Are we talking about the word branded after the publishers name? Completely agree they are publishers not brands, I’ve noticed it’s happening quite a lot on here that. Finding loads lately with the word branded at the end of their names.

I dunno about you but from the MOD response I can’t see this situation improving at all. Feels to me now like a game of cat and mouse, you list a book and see how long it takes for it to be removed pending approval. No confidence at all anymore selling books on here

End of the day they make us sellers jump through hoops when it comes to compliance but yet for them compliance with first sale doctrine doesnt count by the look of it.

20
user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN

Are we talking about the word branded after the publishers name? Completely agree they are publishers not brands, I’ve noticed it’s happening quite a lot on here that. Finding loads lately with the word branded at the end of their names.

I dunno about you but from the MOD response I can’t see this situation improving at all. Feels to me now like a game of cat and mouse, you list a book and see how long it takes for it to be removed pending approval. No confidence at all anymore selling books on here

End of the day they make us sellers jump through hoops when it comes to compliance but yet for them compliance with first sale doctrine doesnt count by the look of it.

20
Reply
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi JillyB,

Things may be legally for sale in the UK but you might not want them on your site, for whatever reason: they might be politically or sexually offensive, in a pharmaseutical grey area or even dangerous...

Where I have difficulty is the removal of items due to potential uncompetitive pricing, when others are allowed to ask higher prices without being banned...

All Best

Brian

10
user profile
Seller_19xPhE8YgkmxW

Hi JillyB,

Things may be legally for sale in the UK but you might not want them on your site, for whatever reason: they might be politically or sexually offensive, in a pharmaseutical grey area or even dangerous...

Where I have difficulty is the removal of items due to potential uncompetitive pricing, when others are allowed to ask higher prices without being banned...

All Best

Brian

10
Reply
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

Just had A&C Black added to the publishers I have to apply for.

Ho-hum, will take my £85 very sellable title and sell elsewhere.

20
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

Just had A&C Black added to the publishers I have to apply for.

Ho-hum, will take my £85 very sellable title and sell elsewhere.

20
Reply
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

Then do something about it.

Put your time in to selling elsewhere instead of continually flogging the dead horse that is Amazon.

user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN
Complete waste of time now bookselling on here and constant battle that’s only going to get worse sooner rather later
View post
10
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

Then do something about it.

Put your time in to selling elsewhere instead of continually flogging the dead horse that is Amazon.

user profile
Seller_vijjPUI46bUSN
Complete waste of time now bookselling on here and constant battle that’s only going to get worse sooner rather later
View post
10
Reply
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

I would bet an awful lot the publishers have every knowledge and are in collusion with Amazon restricting listings, as it's them that benefit by buyers not being able to buy used copies and forced to buy new copies.

user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn
I doubt they have any idea the bots are closing your listings
View post
10
user profile
Seller_FQHkqHJI5SqTh

I would bet an awful lot the publishers have every knowledge and are in collusion with Amazon restricting listings, as it's them that benefit by buyers not being able to buy used copies and forced to buy new copies.

user profile
Seller_eX5PU1b0GGPXn
I doubt they have any idea the bots are closing your listings
View post
10
Reply
Follow this discussion to be notified of new activity